Who should the New York Islanders take with the No. 1 overall pick in the NHL Draft?
Islanders Hold Top Pick in 2025 NHL Draft — Who Should Go No. 1?
The 2025 NHL Draft is fast approaching, and the New York Islanders have won the lottery with the No. 1 overall pick—despite only a 3.5% chance. This year’s draft class is loaded with high-end talent, including defenseman Matthew Schaefer, who is widely projected to go first. Also in the conversation are Saginaw Spirit center Michael Misa, who tallied 134 points last season, and Boston College playmaker James Hagens, known for his elite vision and passing. With so many standout prospects, fans are split on who the Isles should select to help reshape their franchise. The draft begins June 27 in Los Angeles.
Options
- Matthew Schaefer — elite defenseman
- Michael Misa — scoring center
- James Hagens — dynamic playmaker
- Someone else