Which discontinued Girl Scout cookie will you miss the most?
Girl Scouts Retire S’mores and Toast-Yay! Cookies as 2025 Season Rolls Out
The 2025 Girl Scout Cookie season brings both excitement and farewells. This year marks the final appearance of two popular flavors: the graham cracker–coated S’mores and the French toast–inspired Toast‑Yay!. These will be replaced in 2026 by a new Rocky Road–style cookie called Exploremores®. While fan-favorite staples like Thin Mints and Samoas remain, cookie lovers are stocking up on the outgoing varieties. As always, proceeds support local troops and teach entrepreneurial skills. Which flavor will leave the biggest hole in your cookie jar?
Options
- S’mores
- Toast‑Yay!
- Neither
- I’ve never tried them