Should the Supreme Court hear Kim Davis’s appeal over same-sex marriage licenses?
Kim Davis Seeks Supreme Court Showdown Over Same-Sex Marriage Rights
Nearly a decade after refusing to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, former Kentucky clerk Kim Davis is back in the legal spotlight. In 2015, Davis made headlines by citing religious objections to the Supreme Court’s Obergefell v. Hodges ruling. After serving jail time and losing her clerk position, she faced lawsuits and a $100,000 judgment. In 2025, the Sixth Circuit rejected her appeal—but Davis is now petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene. Her legal team argues that forcing her to sign marriage licenses violates her First Amendment rights. The move rekindles national debate around religious freedom, LGBTQ rights, and whether landmark decisions like Obergefell should be reconsidered.
Options
- Yes, it raises valid religious freedom concerns
- No, marriage equality is settled law
- Not sure
- She should not be in court again