How do you view Cardinal Timothy Dolan’s legacy as Archbishop of New York?
Cardinal Timothy Dolan Retires After 16 Years Leading the Archdiocese of New York
On December 18, 2025, Pope Leo XIV accepted the resignation of Cardinal Timothy Dolan, formally ending his tenure as Archbishop of New York after 16 years. Dolan, now 75, steps down as required by Church law, marking a significant leadership transition within the U.S. Catholic Church. He is succeeded by Bishop Ronald Hicks of Joliet, Illinois, who was introduced in a joint appearance at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in Manhattan. Dolan's leadership was known for its media savvy, pastoral presence, and influence in both U.S. and global Catholic affairs — including his role in the election of both Pope Francis and Pope Leo. His legacy includes navigating clergy abuse settlements, public moral debates, and a polarizing but high-profile presence in American religious life. As one of the most visible U.S. Catholic leaders in recent decades, Dolan leaves behind a legacy that is both celebrated and contested.
Options
- Positive — he was a strong public leader
- Mixed — some highs and lows
- Negative — too conservative or political
- Not sure / No opinion