Do you think Josh Naylor deserves his 5-year contract with the Seattle Mariners after his standout 2025 season?
Josh Naylor Inks 5-Year Deal with Mariners After Historic 20 HR/30 SB Season
Josh Naylor, the Canadian-born power-speed first baseman, is finalizing a 5-year contract with the Seattle Mariners after a breakout 2025 MLB season. Naylor, who was traded midseason, helped lead Seattle to the ALCS and put up rare stats for his position: 20 home runs and 30 stolen bases. That combination of power and agility is nearly unprecedented for a first baseman. The deal reportedly cements him as a foundational piece for Seattle’s future roster, with the front office signaling confidence in his long-term value. This performance has elevated his status in both American and Canadian baseball circles. As details of the contract emerge, fans and analysts alike are debating whether Naylor is worth the investment and how he’ll perform under the pressure of a long-term deal.
Options
- Yes — he earned it!
- Too soon to say
- No — risky move
- Not familiar with him